I caught a screening of “Jersey Girl” earlier tonight in Baltimore. I had a lot of reservations going in, based on the less positive reviews on your site and its lackluster to say the least trailer, but I really really loved it. While I will need to rewatch ‘Chasing Amy’ and ‘Dogma’ before I call this his best film, it is by far the most developed and believable characters Smith has ever written.
As I’m sure you all know, the plot consists of Affleck, as Ollie Trinke, attempting to raise his daughter (the amazingly charismatic Raquel Castro) with some help from his father (George Carlin in a pretty endearing performance), after his wife (J.Lo) dies during childbirth in the first 15 minutes. While certain moments fall flat, what really makes the movie work is the relationship between Affleck and Castro. This is actually a believable father-daughter relationship, not simply the kind we usually see in movies. Not only are we shown the unique bond that these two have, but also included is a scene where the two yell incredibly hurtful things at one another, that anyone who has ever had a bitter fight with a parent will recognize. Surprising, even shocking for a Smith film, there were a few moments where myself and several audience members were moved to tears, most notably one of Carlin’s last lines in the movie. All of this leads up to a closing scene that one can only describe as beautiful.
Still, I don’t want to undersell all the funny stuff in this movie, as it is for the most part, a comedy. Well, obviously it is a more family-friendly kind of funny, but it’s still a relatively strong PG-13, with much conversations involving sex and masturbation.
There is a pretty funny subplot involving Ollie’s criticisms of Will Smith that lost him his job, that leads up to a scene that could have been a disaster, but ends up being the best written scene in the movie.
Now, I must say, I hate J. Lo as much as the next guy, but the talk about her opening scenes with Affleck being awful is pure, unadulterated bullshit. This is actually one of the only two movies she didn’t piss me off in (the other being the underrated and forgotten ‘U-Turn’). Her scenes with Affleck come off as genuine and sort of charming in a way.
Liv Tyler plays a video-store clerk who Affleck starts to fall for, and it is hard to remember a more adorable character than Liv plays in this movie. For an actress whose soft-spoken line readings always annoyed me, here she gives a really sweet performance and is downright lovable as the kind of girl we all dream about.
I honestly don’t know why this was pushed till March, while the often painful-to-watch “Cold Mountain” got the big Miramax Oscar push. While this wouldn’t have really had much of a shot for a Best Picture nom, Raquel Castro would’ve been a leading contender for Best Supporting Actress, and possibly even Affleck for Best Actor, in what is definitely the best performance of his career (not saying much for Mr. Reindeer Games I know, but still).
I know many will say this is Smith selling out, but in my opinion, this is really just him maturing as a filmmaker, similar to how I felt “Big Fish” was for Tim Burton.
While it’s not a perfect movie, it’s a bona fide crowd please that doesn’t pander to its audience, is consistently entertaining, and one of the better portrayals of a father-daughter relationship to ever hit the screen.